I have no doubt that anarchy is an impossible way to live. It is hard wired into the physical brains of people to have some sort of organizational structure, for every group of two and above.
There never has been an anarchic society, and there never will be one. But history isn’t a good enough reason, since even though the Bible says there is nothing new under the Sun, saying that there will never be pagers or cell phones because there were none before has been disproven.
Those who espouse anarchy assume that people are basically good, and that left alone, they will strive to go about their business and mind their p’s and q’s. Penn Jillette’s famous “car keys” statement astounds me, since I consider the man a genius in the true sense of the word; that his cognitive reasoning process exceeds us mere average mortals. For you who are not as into Penn & Teller as I am, his quote is
Well, I’m a real total-freedom nut, a libertarian, and I’m one of those crazy optimists. You get this personality type of incredible Pollyanna, dip-shit optimism that just kind of turns out this atheist libertarian who thinks, let people do what they want and everything will be okay. I think, really, the percentage of people on the planet that are actually bad is so small, you don’t even have to consider them. Throw your car keys to everyone; you’re pretty much going to be okay. People just really treat other people, I think, really, really well, and always have, and are getting better all the time. Our crime rates are going down and so on.
How such dreck came from such a brilliant mind, well.
We are encultured to an extent we may never get to know. We are encultured from the first words we here from out of the womb. A temporary anarchy, like the car keys, or even a natural disaster, is not like having an anarchic society. If there is a tornado, and the authorities are away taking care of who they can five miles away and will not get to this area for the next three days, well, everyone knows things will reestablish themselves at that time. That is one thing that keeps people in line. The second is that people will revert to their upbringing. We’ve been encultured for empathy, in the Western Tradition. That is why we get the warm fuzzies from reaching out to help others in a crisis. Even in Nagasaki after the blast, the Japanese did their best to come together and re-knit their society, since they knew that even though that city was so devastated, their country will be back, and they went to work to make it so.
There are places where de facto, if not de jure, anarchy has been in effect, and in none has it ever been pretty. Let’s look at the Somalia situation. Go rent Black Hawk Down for a look at when out Army loses a helicopter in a place run under anarchy. Now that same anarchy has hit the seas in the form of piracy.
There is anarchy in the U.S.A. to study. One of the best books I’ve read is Monster. It is nothing but a testimony to the life that arose in a part of L.A. once the authorities ceded control, and left it to its own devices. The Ivanhoe projects in Gary, Indiana was an area that the Gary police wouldn’t enter unless they were in a team. That miserable project is now shuttered.
Let’s see Europe today. The suburbs of the cities of France, the sad situation of Malmo, Sweden.
Okay, Europe past. There is no hyperbole to overstate the state of anarchy in Germany after the Great War. The free state of Bavaria had literally raised the black flag of anarchism over the region, for Christ sakes. What was the reaction? Well, Hitler took hold in Bavaria before going national.
Let’s look at business, our polite form of anarchic interpersonal relations. Everyone who has been cheated, lied to, swindled, or outright burgled in a business transaction, raise your hand. Once people know there is no structure overseeing their dealings, the sky’s the limit for fraud. The movies Glengarry Glen
Ross and Boiler Room are classics for showing the mechanics of this. Ask anyone who bought a box of bricks he thought was a set of speakers from a guy’s pickup truck in the mall parking lot (I knew a woman whose husband did just that). Once money insulates someone from paying for his crimes, what makes him so moral, if he has no Christian (or other likewise) code? Witness O.J. Simpson, or Klaus von Bulow. Go rent American Psycho.
Critical Mass is a cycling movement that claims to be truly anarchic, with no structure and no leadership. I have participated in CM, and can tell you, there are recognized leaders and an understood structure, much the same, though not as rigid or exclusive as high school cliques.
What I think is a good form is for another post. I’m just here to trash anarchy tonight.
Filed under: Uncategorized